Individual Insurance Market Rules in Utah

State Rule Good, Bad or Ugly?
Getting Affordable Coverage

  • Can insurance companies deny me coverage? 
  • Insurance companies can deny you coverage in Utah. Insurance companies are not required to sell coverage to everyone who applies. That means they can deny you coverage because of anything they find objectionable in your health history. But, some individual marker insurers cannot deny you coverage if you are not eligible for other types of coverage (i.e. group insurance.)


Bad

  • Can insurance companies charge me more than other people for the same policy?  
  • Insurance companies can charge you more than other people for the same policy in Utah. If an insurance company chooses to sell you a policy it can charge you more for the same policy if it believes you pose a higher risk of costing it money, including if you have a pre-existing condition, are older, or are a woman of childbearing age. However, Utah uses “health status rate bands” which limit the amount by which premiums can vary due to health status.


Bad

  • Can insurance companies exclude coverage of my pre-existing condition?  
  • Insurance companies can permanently exclude coverage of your pre-existing condition in Utah. Insurance companies can permanently exclude from coverage any health problems you disclose, or they find in your medical records, at the time of application by an amendment to the individual health insurance contract. This is called an “elimination rider.” However, in Utah insurance companies can put an elimination rider on your policy even if you previously had insurance that covered that condition.


Ugly

  • Can insurance companies make up their own definition of a pre-existing condition? 
  • Insurance companies cannot make up their own definition of a pre-existing condition in Utah. Insurance companies can only consider something a pre-existing condition if the person actually received medical advice, diagnosis, care or treatment for that condition prior to enrollment in the plan. This is called an “objective standard.”


Good

Getting the Care You Need

  • Can insurance companies accept my application for coverage and later search my medical records for an excuse to deny me coverage for needed care?  
  • Insurance companies can accept your application for coverage and later search your medical records for an excuse to deny you coverage for needed care in Utah. If you make a claim for health care services during the first 12 months (one year) of coverage, the insurance company can search your medical history up to 6 months prior to the purchase of your policy looking for evidence that your current health problem was pre-existing. If the insurance company finds any such evidence, it can deny you coverage for that condition.


Good

  • Can insurance companies pay their doctors incentives to provide me with less care?
  • Insurance companies can pay their doctors incentives to provide you with less care in Utah. An insurance company can pay health care providers incentives to withhold covered care.


Ugly

  • Can I appeal an insurance company’s denial of care to an outside entity? 
  • A member of any health plan can appeal any denial of coverage to an outside entity in Utah. An appeal must be filed with the Commissioner of Insurance; there is no time limit or fee for filing.


Good

  • Can I sue my insurance company if it denies medically necessary care that causes me or a loved-one harm?  
  • You cannot sue your insurance company if it denies medically necessary care that causes you or a loved-one harm in Utah. You cannot sue an insurance company for any harm that may have resulted from its denial of coverage or benefits.


Ugly

SOURCE: Kaiser Family Foundation State Health Facts, 2007

- To learn about all your rights and protections in the individual insurance market, contact the Utah Department of Insurance.

LATEST SCORECARD

Half of U.S. Doctors Report Insurance Restricts Medications or Treatment Decisions

Fifty-eight percent of primary care doctors in the U.S. report their patients often have difficulty paying for medications and care, and half of U.S. doctors spend substantial time dealing with restrictions insurance companies place on their patients’ care, according to the 2009 Commonwealth Fund International Health Policy Survey.


LEARN MORE
Family Premiums for Employer-Sponsored Coverage Rose About 5%

Families saw their premiums for job-based health insurance rise to an average of $13,375 annually in 2009, with workers paying an average share of $3,515 and employers paying $9,860.


LEARN MORE
health care in your state